Independent rate comparison. No bank pays for a place in our tables. Verify rates directly.

Updated 28 October 2026

Brokered CD Rates: Fidelity vs Schwab vs Vanguard vs Bank Direct (2026)

Brokered CDs are purchased through a brokerage rather than directly from a bank. They offer some unique advantages: secondary market liquidity, FDIC coverage across multiple issuing banks from one account, and sometimes competitive rates. Here is how they compare to the best direct bank CDs.

How Brokered CDs Work

When you buy a brokered CD through Fidelity, Schwab, or Vanguard, you are buying a CD issued by a bank that the brokerage has a relationship with. The CD shows up in your brokerage account alongside your stocks and bonds. Key differences from bank CDs:

  • Simple interest: Most brokered CDs pay simple interest (not compound), typically semi-annually.
  • Secondary market: You can sell before maturity on the secondary market rather than paying a fixed penalty. Price fluctuates with interest rates.
  • FDIC via issuing bank: Coverage is at the issuing bank, up to $250,000. Buying from multiple issuers spreads your coverage; you choose the issuer of each CD.
  • No direct bank relationship: You do not need an account at the issuing bank.

Rate Comparison: Bank Direct and Treasuries, the Benchmarks for a Brokered CD

Fidelity shows its new-issue CD yields only inside its CD search, and Schwab's public CD page carries no as-of date, so we do not quote brokerage yields here. Use these two published benchmarks instead: a brokered CD should beat the best bank-direct APY or the Treasury of the same term to be worth buying.

TermBest bank direct APYTreasury yield
6-Month4.35%Popular Direct4.34%
1-Year4.60%Popular Direct4.50%
2-Year4.75%Barclays (US online)4.70%
5-Year4.75%Synchrony Bank4.82%

Bank direct: highest APY in our table, read from each bank's own rate page on 28 October 2026. Treasury: US Treasury daily par yield curve for 27 October 2026 (home.treasury.gov), a bond-equivalent yield, not an APY.

Pros and Cons of Brokered CDs

Advantages

  • Secondary market liquidity: Sell before maturity instead of paying a fixed penalty. Useful if rates drop (you sell at a premium).
  • FDIC spread in one account: Buy CDs from multiple issuing banks in one brokerage account. Each is insured up to $250K at its issuing bank.
  • Consolidated management: All CDs in one account alongside stocks and bonds. No multiple bank logins.
  • No early withdrawal penalty: Instead of a fixed penalty, you sell on the secondary market. If rates have fallen, you may even profit.

Disadvantages

  • Simple interest: Most brokered CDs do not compound. At 4.00% over 5 years on $25,000 that is about $5,000 of simple interest versus about $5,416 compounded annually, unless you reinvest the payouts yourself.
  • Market risk on early exit: If rates rise after you buy, selling early means selling at a loss. Bank CD penalties are more predictable.
  • More complex: Understanding new-issue vs secondary market, simple vs compound interest, and mark-to-market pricing requires more financial literacy.

How to Buy a Brokered CD

Step 1: Open or log into your brokerage account.

Step 2: Navigate to Fixed Income or CD section.

Step 3: Filter by term length. Review available CDs, noting the issuing bank, rate, and maturity date.

Step 4: Buy new-issue CDs (at par) or secondary market CDs (may trade above or below par).

When Brokered CDs Beat Bank CDs

Large deposits ($250K+): Brokered CDs let you spread FDIC coverage across multiple issuing banks you choose. No need to open accounts at 3-5 different banks.

Rate volatility expectations: If you expect rates to drop significantly, buying a brokered CD lets you sell at a premium on the secondary market before maturity, capturing a capital gain on top of the interest.

Portfolio integration: If you manage all investments through one brokerage, adding CDs to the same account simplifies tax reporting and portfolio tracking.

In most other cases: Bank direct CDs are better. They compound interest and have predictable penalties. Compare the issuer's yield on the brokerage CD board with the bank-direct APYs below before you choose.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a brokered CD?▾

A brokered CD is a certificate of deposit purchased through a brokerage (Fidelity, Schwab, Vanguard) rather than directly from a bank. The brokerage buys CDs from various issuing banks and sells them to investors. Each CD is still FDIC insured at the issuing bank up to $250,000.

Do brokered CDs compound interest?▾

Most brokered CDs pay simple interest rather than compound interest. This means interest is paid out periodically (usually semi-annually) rather than being reinvested into the CD. The gap is small on short terms and grows with the term: at 4.00% a year for 5 years, $10,000 earns $2,000 of simple interest, or about $2,167 if the interest compounds annually.

Can I sell a brokered CD before maturity?▾

Yes. Unlike bank CDs where you pay an early withdrawal penalty, brokered CDs can be sold on the secondary market through your brokerage. However, the price may be above or below your purchase price depending on current interest rates. If rates have risen, you may sell at a loss. If rates have fallen, you may sell at a premium.

How do I buy a brokered CD?▾

Log into your brokerage account at Fidelity, Schwab, or Vanguard. Navigate to their CD/fixed income section. You can buy new-issue CDs (sold at par) or secondary market CDs. Select your term, review the issuing bank and rate, and place your order. The listing shows the minimum purchase.

Not in the table

When the rate sheet stops short of your question

Send it over. A person opens everything that arrives, and the reply points at the page the number came from and the day it was read, so you can go and check the same thing we checked. How an APY is worked out, how the comparison here was assembled, what an early withdrawal actually costs you in dollars, why one term pays more than a longer one: all of that is squarely in scope.

Nothing leaves the inbox without being asked. Where an answer would help other savers, we write back and ask, and only an anonymised version of it is ever published.

None of this is financial advice, and no reply will be a recommendation to open an account. We are not a bank, a broker or a deposit marketplace, and we cannot open, move or close an account for anyone.

Posted rates change daily, so the institution’s own current disclosure and the APY printed on it are the figures that settle any argument with this site. FDIC and NCUA coverage limits are set by those agencies, not by us.

Updated 2026-10-28